Shoule you be vegetarian?
Argument presented in prose
Argument presented in prose
Do you think your local butcher will reduce the amount of meat she orders from the slaughterhouse if you become a vegetarian? Of course not! The supply chain for meat just isn’t sensitive to the quantities that a single person consumes. So by becoming a vegetarian, you'll never save a single animal’s life! But by becoming a vegetarian you’ll deprive yourself of the pleasure of eating meat, and you should only do that if the benefits would outweigh the losses. So you should only become a vegetarian if doing so would save some animals’ lives.
Model visualization
Model visualization
Can you figure out what's wrong with this argument?